Finally Played: Spirit Island

 Despite having been into table top gaming for a while now, there are a few games that always surprise people when say that I've never played them. These games are modern classics, staples of the table top scene, that almost any board game fan would usually have played early on in their gaming journey. 

In this new series, I am aiming to put that right and get as many of these games to the table as possible. Many are considered entry-level games for those new to the hobby, so will they stand up to someone coming at them from the other end of the spectrum?

Kicking off this series I sought out Spirit Island by R. Eric Reuss. While this isn't often considered a starter-game, it is widely regarded as a modern classic so it surprises me that I'd never had the opportunity to play it. 

Spirit Island, R. Eric Reuss - Greater Than Games

Spirit Island is a cooperative, anti-colonialist game. Players take the roles of the eponymous Spirits to defend the island from destructive colonisers and protect the indigenous population using their mystical powers. The spirits powers range from outright destruction to moving the enemy colonisers around the board, making them easier targets for other players. 

Each round consists of players levelling up their spirits, choosing actions, and then playing them out either before of after the colonists depending on the speed of the action. On the colonisers' turn they explore, build, and ravage different sections of the island, expanding their presence or spreading blight. The amount of blight dictates the overall health of the island and is difficult to remove. If too much blight is placed, the island becomes irreparably damaged, implying that even if you are successful in repelling the invaders, it comes at a cost.

Building on the narrative of the cost of removing the colonists, is the progression of the spirits themselves. As they level up they gain access to more and more powerful actions, which soon start to include negative effects as well. Yes, you can remove all the towns and cities from a space on the board, but you also must place a blight, or you destroy all the natives while you're at it. This helps establish a nuanced story in the course of play that really highlights the short and long term impacts of colonialism on native populations. Even if they are successful and manage to defend their island, it comes at a cost that they will be dealing with for years to come.

The game tells the story of invasion in a way that doesn't hold any punches. Players will start out feeling like the underdog defenders and it's easy to become overwhelmed by the sheer amount that is going on on the board. At the start of the game, the spirits are weak and ill-equipped to deal with the growing problem, but as they grow, more interesting and useful powers are unlocked. Through this progression players find their feet little by little and learn how they can work together to make the most out of their actions. The game is undeniably hard, but in an historical sense, it needs to be. It would be unfair on real-world indigenous populations if repelling colonisers was portrayed as something straight forward or easy. That being said, it did at times feel like the indigenous people, the Dahan, lacked agency and were a passive entity on the board, waiting for the spirits to deal with their problems. 

The game itself is a mixture of strategy, area control, and deck building, all of which are fairly well executed. There was also a satisfying crunchiness to the amount that was going on on the board. There's a lot of game here to sink your teeth into.

That being said, I found myself slightly underwhelmed with the game as a whole. The gameplay often felt a bit clunky and I found that as a new player I was getting frustrated at how difficult it was to take meaningful actions on my turn. There is definitely a high amount of strategy needed and there is very little luck involved. Personally, I like games to have a degree of chance to be truly engaging, and I think that Spirit Island is missing this. The only real element of the game that was left up to chance was which environments would be targeted by the colonisers, but as they were constantly all over the board anyway, it felt like everywhere was constantly under attack

The game generally has a nice art style, portrayed on the player's spirit boards and action cards, but I feel it is let down by the board itself, which looks fairly bland, even when covered with tokens and counters.

Overall, I can completely understand why this game is as popular as it is. There's plenty of scope for improving your skill and strategy on consecutive plays, learning how the game wants to be played. For me, however, the fantastic theme and mostly good artwork failed to stick the landing when it came to gameplay. I never felt like a mighty spirit of nature. More accurately, I felt a little lost and confused. Perhaps it was because we were all new players, but it didn't flow in a satisfying way and at times felt downright messy. I love the theme and would like to see more anti-colonial games, but I don't think Spirit Island is for me. It's possible that with more plays I would learn to love it, but I just don't know if there is enough there to draw me back in. Call it a skill issue, if you will, but the game failed to draw me in.

Regardless of my feelings, I am pleased to have finally managed to sit and play this game.